Memory for Idiots (like me)

Just a collection of my notes from my time learning C,
I'd tried learning C a couple of times but it took a while for it to really click in my head

Analogy


Essentially the CPU cache is like a tub of water you have at home (program), But since it's at home, its very fast to access it.
The stack is like a outdoor water tank, still very fast to access but slower than the cache and you can access a lot more water at once too.
The heap is like a village well, It takes time to get to it but once you're there, you can effectivley get as much water as you want.

There technically, is a much more nuanced difference between the stack and the heap and they can be entirely just in one's head but it makes explaining stuff a lot simpler.

Example Problem: Returning a string from a function

Let's say we want to write a function in C to return a string time stamp, Very simple right?

Initial Attempt:

char *getTimestamp() {
    char timestamp[100];
    snprintf(timestamp, sizeof(timestamp), "%llu", time(NULL));
    return timestamp;
}	
But this won't work, The compiler even gives us a warning
e.c:6:12: warning: function returns address of local variable [-Wreturn-local-addr]
    6 |     return timestamp;
      |            ^~~~~

Okay but why doesn't this work? It's because our timestamp variable doesnt exist anymore once timestamp returns, So the pointer we return is pointing to garbage.
There's three ways we can fix it, By marking our memory static, By taking a char buffer as a argument or by allocating our memory so that it won't disapper once our function is complete.

📜 Plain old data types can be simply passed around without any memory shenanigans, This is most efficient for smaller structures

Solution 1: static

char *getTimestamp() {
    static char timestamp[100];
    snprintf(timestamp, sizeof(timestamp), "%llu");
    return timestamp;
}	
This works, because now timestamp is static so it will exist for the lifetime of the program, But the problem is if the function is called again, timestamp gets overwritten!
Example:
char*a = getTimestamp();
printf("%s\n",a);
sleep(5);
char*b = getTimestamp();
printf("%s, %s\n",a,b);	
gives
1682173737
1682173742, 1682173742

so the memory a is pointing to changes when getTimestamp() is called again.

NOTE: static memory is only initialized once

Solution 2: taking a pointer

char *getTimestamp(char* buf, size_t bufSize) {
    snprintf(buf, bufSize, "%llu", time(NULL));
    return buf;
}	
In this version, we ignore memory entirely, We simply take in a pointer to some memory (stack or heap, doesn't matter) and write to it.
But if we didn't take in a size for the buffer there's a chance we could overflow the buffer. So there is added risk with this, but it allows for better memory reusability, since the caller can call it with the same memory.

Solution 3: allocating on the heap

// Caller must free() the given memory
char* getTimestamp() {
    char* timestamp = malloc(100);
    snprintf(buf, 100, "%llu", time(NULL));
    return timestamp;   
}	
In this case, each time our function is called, we allocate a tiny buffer and write to it, This isn't the best solution for this particular problem since allocating such a small chunk wastes time, But if we are dealing with bigger chunks, It's a good solution

Conclusion

Solution 1 has the chance of corruption so it's kind of impractical but if you know you won't need the previous result again then it is fine.
Solution 2 & 3 both offload some work on the callee, namely allocating / freeing memory.

Solution 2 might also need a sanity check for bufSize being sufficient and the pointer not being NULL.
Solution 3 could cause a memory leak if the caller forgets to free the memory.

So it's important to pick the correct solution for the problem at hand, in this case, Solution 2 or 3 would be good.

Pointers Primer

Pointers are simply (64bit integer) addresses to somewhere in memory, They can either point to nothing (NULL) or a valid memory address.
Pointers usually are associated with a certain type but since C doesn't have generics, It's commonplace to cast them to void* which can then be casted again to any type you wish.

Whenever you want to give a function access to something without giving it a whole copy of it (Nothing wrong with this for small things), you use a pointer.

You can obtain the address of local variables with the & operator.

C arrays are contiguous in memory meaning that each element is directly after another so if you know the element size, You can loop through the array with only pointers,
This can be useful if you don't know the size of the array but you know that it terminates in NULL

void example(char** strArray) {
    char* str = strArray;
    while(str != NULL) {
        printf("%s\t",str);
        str += sizeof(char*);
    }
}	

The biggest difference between a 32bit architecture and 64bit is that in 32bit, the pointers are only 32bits long (4bytes) which limits memory size to 4GB, on 64bit they are double the size so can access as much as 16 exabytes of memory.

More on pointers

Type Bytes
int 4
short 2
void* 8
float 4
double 8
char 1
long 8
llu 8
size_t 8
ptrdiff_t 8

NOTE: Size of integer types tends to vary according to platform If you need exactly sized integers use stdint.h manpage


Handling Memory

Note: In case of encountering an error like insufficient memory, these functions will return NULL and set errno, See the manpage.

malloc

Get unitialized memory

calloc

Get zero initialized memory

aligned_alloc

Get uninitialized memory aligned on a given boundry


Whenever you wish to resize your given block of memory, realloc is used.
manpage

mmap

This is a linux syscall for mapping pages of memory but it can be useful for certain things like,
Loading a entire file into memory:

int fd = open("passwd", O_RDONLY);
struct stat s;
fstat(fd, &s);
char *buffer = mmap(0, s.st_size, PROT_READ | PROT_WRITE, MAP_PRIVATE, fd, 0);
buffer[s.st_size-1] = '\0';
printf("%s",buffer);
munmap(buffer, s.st_size);	

Writing to a file:
char *str = "Hello World";
int fd = open("test", O_RDWR | O_CREAT);
ftruncate(fd, strlen(str)+1);
char* buffer = mmap(0, strlen(str)+1, PROT_READ | PROT_WRITE, MAP_SHARED, fd, 0);
memcpy(buffer, str, strlen(str)+1);
msync(buffer, strlen(str)+1, MS_SYNC);
munmap(buffer, strlen(str)+1);	
Full example
manpage

alloca

This is used to sort of pretend the stack works like the heap and can be used to allocate memory on the stack, The benefit is that it will automatically be freed and it's possible that the memory returned will be faster to access,
But with alloca you can never know if the allocation failed or not since if the allocation causes stack overflow, behaviour is not defined.
manpage

Leaks

Unfortunatley we aren't always forget and it is all too easy to forget to ever free a block of memory.
This isn't bad when the chunk is small but it's best to try to plug all the big leaks you can since it can crash your application or slow it down a lot.

-fsanitize=address

These days any program compiled with AddressSanitizer (ASAN) should automatically any leaks in it even with line numbers.

int main(void) {
	char* rand = malloc(100);
	rand[99] = '\0';
	printf("%s\n", rand);
	// No free: free(rand);
}	
when compiled with asan (& debug info) will give
=================================================================
==16713==ERROR: LeakSanitizer: detected memory leaks

Direct leak of 100 byte(s) in 1 object(s) allocated from:
    #0 0x29a2cd in malloc (/tmp/e+0x29a2cd)
    #1 0x2c9f21 in main /tmp/e.c:3:15
    #2 0x7fe53f6ead09 in __libc_start_main csu/../csu/libc-start.c:308:16

SUMMARY: AddressSanitizer: 100 byte(s) leaked in 1 allocation(s).


Valgrind

An external tool called valgrind can also be used to find memory leaks
NOTE: Asan and valgrind aren't compatible with each other
It can even report other stuff like using uninitialized values etc.

$ valgrind --leak-check=full ./e
...
==18045== 100 bytes in 1 blocks are definitely lost in loss record 1 of 1
==18045==    at 0x483877F: malloc (vg_replace_malloc.c:307)
==18045==    by 0x201171: main (e.c:3)
...


Other Documents

Beej's Guide to C: https://beej.us/guide/bgc/html/split/
Beej's Guide to the C stdlib: https://beej.us/guide/bgclr/html/split/
https://www.rfleury.com/p/untangling-lifetimes-the-arena-allocator